Self-Reported Attribution vs Software Led Attribution: Which is More Accurate for Measuring Marketing Effectiveness?

Measuring the effectiveness of marketing efforts is essential for any business, but it can be particularly challenging for B2B marketers. Traditional web analytics tools often rely on cookies and tracking pixels to measure the effectiveness of marketing campaigns. Still, these methods can be unreliable and may not accurately reflect the customer journey. 

In this blog, we’ll explore the difference between software-based and self-reported attribution and discuss the pros and cons of each approach. 

By understanding the differences between these methods, B2B marketers can choose the right approach for their business and gain valuable insights into the impact of their marketing efforts.


Want to learn how to deliver long-term sustainable growth for your business? 

Take a look at The Big Book of SaaS: A Founders Guide to B2B SaaS Growth


What is self-reported attribution?

Self-reported attribution is a method of measuring the effectiveness of marketing efforts that relies on the feedback of customers and prospects. This method involves asking customers and prospects how they heard about a business and using this information to attribute the success of a marketing campaign to specific channels and tactics. In this article, we’ll explore the concept of self-reported attribution and discuss why it’s important for B2B marketers to understand and consider in their strategies.

One of the key benefits of self-reported attribution is that it provides a more accurate picture of the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics. Traditional web analytics tools often rely on cookies and tracking pixels to measure the effectiveness of marketing efforts. Still, these methods can be unreliable and may not accurately reflect the customer journey. By asking customers and prospects how they heard about the business, B2B marketers can gain insights into the most effective channels and tactics to drive awareness and conversions.

Another benefit of self-reported attribution is that it can help B2B marketers to better understand and engage with their audience. By asking customers and prospects how they heard about the business, B2B marketers can gain insights into the preferences and behaviour of their target audience. This can help them create and promote relevant and valuable content to their audience and tailor their marketing efforts to the needs and preferences of their target audience.

New call-to-action

What is software-led attribution?

Software-led attribution is a method of measuring the effectiveness of marketing efforts that uses specialised software to track and attribute the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics. While this method can provide valuable insights into the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics, it also has several limitations that can make it problematic for B2B marketers.

One of the key problems with software-led attribution is that it relies on cookies and tracking pixels to measure the effectiveness of marketing efforts. While these methods can provide valuable insights, they can also be unreliable and may not accurately reflect the customer journey. For example, if a customer clicks on a link in an email but then decides to visit the website directly later on, the software may not attribute the marketing campaign’s success to the email, even though it played a role in the customer’s decision-making process.

Another problem with software-led attribution is that it can be difficult to attribute the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics. For example, if a customer sees an ad on social media and then clicks on a link in an email to make a purchase, it can be difficult for the software to determine which channel or tactic was most effective in driving the conversion. This can make it difficult for B2B marketers to accurately measure the effectiveness of their marketing efforts and optimise their performance.

Attribution platforms can be expensive and require significant resources to implement and maintain. B2B marketers may need to invest in specialised software, training, and dedicated staff to manage and analyze the data. This can be a significant investment, particularly for small and medium-sized businesses.

While software-led attribution can provide valuable insights into the customer journey, it also has several limitations that can make it problematic for B2B marketers. By understanding these limitations, B2B marketers can weigh the pros and cons of software-led attribution and determine whether it is the right approach for their business.

What software is used in B2B marketing to track attribution? 

Several different types of software can be used in B2B marketing to track attribution. Some of the most common examples include:

Marketing Automation Software

Marketing automation software is designed to help businesses automate and manage their marketing efforts. This type of software often includes features for tracking and attributing the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics.

Some examples of B2B marketing automation software include:

  • HubSpot: HubSpot is a comprehensive marketing automation platform that includes features for email marketing, social media marketing, content management, and more.
  • Pardot: Pardot is a B2B marketing automation platform that includes features for lead generation, lead nurturing, and sales insights.
  • Marketo: Marketo is a marketing automation platform that includes email marketing, lead management, and analytics features.
  • Act-On: Act-On is a marketing automation platform that includes email marketing, lead management, and website personalization features.
  • Eloqua: Eloqua is a marketing automation platform that includes lead management, email marketing, and predictive analytics features.

Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Software

CRM software is designed to help businesses manage their relationships with customers and prospects. This type of software often includes features for tracking and attributing the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics.

Some examples of CRMs software used for attribution include:

  • Salesforce: Salesforce is a cloud-based CRM platform that provides various tools for managing customer relationships, including lead and contact management, sales forecasting, and marketing automation.
  • HubSpot: HubSpot has a CRM platform that offers a range of tools for managing customer relationships, including contact and lead management, sales forecasting, and marketing automation.
  • Zoho CRM: Zoho CRM is a cloud-based platform that offers a range of tools for managing customer relationships, including lead and contact management, sales forecasting, and marketing automation.
  • Microsoft Dynamics 365: Microsoft Dynamics 365 is a cloud-based CRM platform that offers a range of tools for managing customer relationships, including lead and contact management, sales forecasting, and marketing automation.

Analytics Software

Analytics software is designed to help businesses collect, analyze, and interpret data about their marketing efforts. This type of software often includes features for tracking and attributing the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics. Some examples of B2B marketing analytics software include:

  • Google Analytics: Google Analytics is a free web analytics service that provides detailed insights into website traffic and performance.
  • Mixpanel: Mixpanel is an analytics platform that provides detailed insights into customer behaviour and engagement.
  • Adobe Analytics: Adobe Analytics is a comprehensive analytics platform that provides detailed insights into customer behaviour and the effectiveness of marketing campaigns.
  • Tableau: Tableau is a data visualization tool that helps businesses to analyze and interpret data about their marketing efforts.

Overall, B2B marketers can use various software tools to track and attribute the success of their marketing campaigns. By choosing the right software for their business and incorporating it into their marketing strategy, B2B marketers can gain valuable insights into the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics.

New call-to-action

What is the difference between self-reported attribution and software-led attribution?

Self-reported and software-led attribution are two methods of measuring marketing effectiveness. While both methods can provide valuable insights into the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics, there are several key differences between the two approaches.

Self-reported attribution involves asking customers and prospects how they heard about a business and using this information to attribute the success of marketing activity to specific content, channels and tactics. One of the key benefits of self-reported attribution is that it provides a more direct and accurate picture of the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics. However, it can also be subject to bias and may not provide a complete picture.

Software-led attribution, on the other hand, involves using specialised software to track and attribute the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics. This method relies on cookies and tracking pixels to measure marketing effectiveness and provide detailed insights into the customer journey. 

However, it can also be unreliable and may not accurately reflect the customer journey. The algorithms used to determine attribution can be limited in the ability to consider the complex and nuanced ways in which different marketing efforts can interact and influence customer behaviour. Additionally, software-led attribution may not consider other factors affecting customer behaviour, such as offline, social media and network-related influences. As a result, software-led attribution can produce inaccurate results, leading to incorrect conclusions about the effectiveness of different marketing efforts.

How can B2B marketers incorporate self-reported attribution into their marketing strategies? 

Here are a few tips:

Include a question about the customer journey on forms. Something as simple as “where did you hear about us?” in your conversion forms using a mandatory field. By asking customers and prospects how they heard about the business, B2B marketers can gain valuable insights into the channels and tactics most effectively driving awareness and conversions.

Use customer service interactions as an opportunity to gather feedback: Customer service interactions can also provide valuable insights into the customer journey. By asking customers and prospects how they heard about the business during customer service interactions, B2B marketers can better understand the channels and tactics driving awareness and conversions.

Analyze the data and adjust your strategy accordingly: Once you have collected data on the customer journey through self-reported attribution, it’s important to analyse and adjust your marketing strategy accordingly. By identifying the channels and tactics most effective at driving awareness and conversions, B2B marketers can focus their efforts on the most effective channels and tactics and optimize their marketing performance.

Self-reported attribution is a valuable method for measuring the effectiveness of marketing efforts for B2B businesses. By incorporating it into their marketing strategies, B2B marketers can gain valuable insights into the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics. By analyzing the data and adjusting their strategy accordingly, B2B marketers can optimize their marketing performance and drive more awareness and conversions for their business.

Conclusion

In conclusion, self-reported attribution and software-led attribution are two methods of measuring the effectiveness of marketing efforts in the B2B space. While both methods can provide valuable insights into the customer journey and the impact of different marketing channels and tactics, there are several key differences between the two approaches. 

Self-reported attribution involves asking customers and prospects how they heard about a business. In contrast, software-led attribution involves using specialised software to track and attribute the success of marketing campaigns to specific channels and tactics. By understanding the pros and cons of each approach, B2B marketers can choose the right method for their business and incorporate it into their marketing strategy.

New call-to-action

Self-Reported Attribution vs Software Led Attribution FAQs

What is self-reported attribution, and how does it work?

Self-reported attribution is a method of tracking and attributing the success of a marketing campaign by asking customers how they heard about a business or product. This information is typically collected through surveys or asking customers directly during interactions such as sales calls or in-person meetings.

Self-reported attribution works by gathering information directly from customers about the specific marketing touchpoints that led them to make a purchase or take a desired action. This information can then be used to evaluate the effectiveness of different marketing channels and tactics and make decisions about where to allocate resources in the future. It's important to remember that self-reported attribution is based on the customer's memory and can be subjective, so it's a good idea to combine it with other attribution methods.

How can self-reported attribution improve my marketing efforts?

Self-reported attribution can improve your marketing efforts by providing valuable insights into the customer journey and how different marketing tactics perform. This information can be used to make data-driven decisions about where to allocate resources and optimize campaigns for maximum ROI.

Some of the ways self-reported attribution can improve your marketing efforts include:

Identifying the most effective marketing channels: By tracking which channels customers say they were exposed to before making a purchase or taking a desired action, you can determine which channels are driving the most conversions and allocate more resources to those channels.

Optimizing campaigns: By understanding which tactics work best, you can optimize your campaigns to improve performance and increase conversions.

Improving targeting: By understanding which demographics, interests, or behaviours are associated with customers who take a desired action, you can improve your targeting to reach more of the right people.

Tracking the customer journey: By understanding the specific steps customers take before making a purchase or taking a desired action, you can identify any bottlenecks or pain points in the customer journey and take steps to address them.

Allowing for more accurate budgeting: By understanding which channels, tactics, and campaigns are driving the most conversions, you can make more accurate predictions about future performance and budget accordingly.

How can I ensure that my self-reported attribution data is accurate?

To ensure that your self-reported attribution data is as accurate as possible, here are a few best practices you can follow:

Use multiple methods of data collection: Self-reported data can be prone to bias, so it's a good idea to gather data from multiple sources, such as surveys, customer interviews, and in-person interactions. This will help ensure that the data is more representative of the population.

Use open-ended questions: Using open-ended questions rather than multiple-choice options when gathering data can help ensure that you capture the full range of responses, not just those that fit into pre-determined categories.

Be mindful of recall bias: Remember that self-reported data is based on the customer's memory, so there may be a recall bias. It's important to ask questions in a way that's as objective as possible and avoid asking customers to recall events that took place a long time ago.

Use a control group: To ensure the accuracy of your data, it's a good idea to use a control group, a group of customers exposed to the same marketing efforts but didn't make a purchase. This will help you understand the reliability of the self-reported data.

Use a third-party tool: To avoid any bias, it's a good idea to use a third-party tool or survey software to gather data, this way, you can ensure that the data is collected unbiasedly and is easy to analyze.

Verification: You can verify the self-reported data with other data sources such as website analytics, CRM, and other systems. This will help you understand the reliability of the self-reported data.

By following these best practices, you can help ensure that your self-reported attribution data is as accurate as possible and can be used to make informed decisions about your marketing efforts.

How do I get started with self-reported attribution for my business?

To get started with self-reported attribution for your business, you should determine the metrics you want to track and measure. This could include website traffic, conversions, revenue, or other important metrics for your business.

Next, you should set up tracking and measurement tools, such as Google Analytics, to track these metrics. After that, you should establish a process for regularly reviewing and analyzing the data you collect and use this information to make informed decisions about your marketing and advertising efforts.

It's also a good idea to consult with a specialist in attribution modelling to help you set up and optimize your self-reported attribution system.

In This Article

    Let's Grow Your Business

    Join the 5,000+ Growth Essentials subscribers who get the latest updates sent directly to their inbox every month.